flaw: terms themselves are not well defined. Stated and unstated feeling; language compressor; personal thermometer; siamese twin example; state of data capture; needs an explanatory theory of qualia

If genes code for thick butts and that makes girls happier than what if society's beauty definition changes -- all your science is out the window

Usually you get the people equivocate: "but the effect is still there", but that's just talking about correlate and not causal. It’s not an explanation